Casa Reyes

4.9 (185 reviews )
$$
Mexican Restaurant
Outdoor seating
Kerbside pickup
Takeaway
Dine-in
+(12)

About Casa Reyes

Casa Reyes is a Mexican restaurant located in Schaghticoke, NY, with a price range of $10–20. It is known for fresh, homemade dishes including various tacos, burritos, and traditional desserts, along with house-made sauces and beverages like horchata. Customers frequently highlight the quality and freshness of the food as well as the friendly and efficient service.

While the restaurant does not have a public restroom, featuring only an outdoor portable toilet, it is well-regarded for takeout and large orders. The bright decor and outdoor seating with scenic views contribute to a pleasant dining atmosphere. Casa Reyes is favored by locals for consistent flavors, timely service, and authentic Mexican cuisine prepared with fresh ingredients.

Reviews (185) 4.9

  • Hiram Bates
    Mar 12,2026

    Food is great! Everything was fresh. One caution if you plan on dining there is that they do not have a public restroom. There is a Porte potty outside. I would recommend especially for takeout.

  • Seth Leech
    Mar 12,2026

    Amazing restaurant. Food is fresh, homemade and delicious. We loved the tacos (alambre, barbacoa and chorizo), burritos, sauces and desserts (churros and flan). The homemade horchata was a treat.

  • Brittany Fiorino
    Mar 12,2026

    Our workplace often orders large lunch orders. It is consistently ready on time, delicious, and the service is friendly and efficient. We are extremely lucky to have a place like Casa Reyes in Washington County. Give them all your dollars for all the tacos/burritos/etc. and you will not be disappointed.

  • Kat Guilfoyle
    Mar 12,2026

    Went with my kids after shopping at Willard Mountain. We've been meaning to stop by for years and I'm glad we finally did! Casa Reyes is the real deal! One of my kids said his pollo tacos were the best tacos he's ever had & my pollo burrito was the best burrito I've ever had! Beautiful, bright decor & very friendly people! Highly recommend!

  • BOLT
    Mar 12,2026

    You should absolutely give this gem a try, wish I didn't wait until my friend encouraged me to try it on my mail route. A new favorite location, a great way to support local and feed your family great food!

  • Courtney Williams
    Mar 12,2026

    This place is seriously my favorite! I’ve tried almost everything on the menu so far and everything is delicious especially the two sauces that come with the order as well. always on point with flavor and freshness!

  • Andrea Ramirez
    Mar 12,2026

    Casa Reyes. Completely worth the drive, incredible tortillas, fresh asada, al pastor and alambre, best salsas too. We enjoyed guacamole I am from Jalisco & these tacos are so deliciosos !

  • Natalie Smarro
    Mar 12,2026

    What an incredible gem with an incredible view!! We had the freshest food with wonderful service. We sat outdoors and enjoyed this delicious food while the sun set. We’ll drive the 50 minutes again just to enjoy this special restaurant.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What are some popular dishes at Casa Reyes?

    The tacos (alambre, barbacoa, chorizo), burritos, churros, and flan are crowd favorites, all made fresh and homemade.

  • Can I make a reservation or do I need to walk in?

    Casa Reyes accepts reservations but also welcomes walk-ins, making it easy to plan your visit.

  • Does Casa Reyes offer different dining options?

    Yes, you can dine in, take away, use kerbside pickup, or have your food delivered for convenience.

  • What is the atmosphere like at Casa Reyes?

    The restaurant is casual, cozy, and quiet, great for families, solo diners, locals, and tourists alike.

  • Is parking available and what payment methods are accepted?

    There is free parking including a parking lot and street parking, and they accept credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Nearby Mexican restaurants

Mexican Restaurant
Cabo Fresh - Commack

5026 Jericho Tpke, Commack, NY 11725, United States

Mexican Restaurant
El Tio Tamale Cart

Nassau & Manhattan av.TrenG, Brooklyn, NY 11222, United States

Mexican Restaurant
Taqueria sabor mexico

113 Main St, Ossining, NY 10562, United States

Mexican Restaurant
Mirabella Cocina Latina

1 Hamilton St Suite A, Dobbs Ferry, NY 10522, United States

Mexican restaurant
Viva Tulum

844 Merrick Rd, Baldwin, NY 11510, United States

Mexican restaurant
El Paso Los Contreras

54 Quassaick Ave, New Windsor, NY 12553, United States

Mexican restaurant
Pollo Poblano

204 New Main St, Yonkers, NY 10701, United States

Mexican restaurant
Tacos CDMX

118 W Green St, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

Mexican restaurant
La Morenita Market- Mexican Restaurant

89 Cottage St, Middletown, NY 10940, United States

Mexican restaurant
Camelitas

400 Fulton Ave # C, Hempstead, NY 11550, United States

Are you the owner?

Claim this page to update business information and manage your presence.

Claim this page Claim this page